Scores from leading critics

The table below shows scores from key Bordeaux wine critics. It will be updated as the campaign unfolds. To view their full reports and tasting notes, please click through and subscribe to the relevant publication. You can find links behind their initials on the top row, or in the key at the bottom of the page.

Wine name JA JD AG JH MJ CK JL  JM LPB JMQ GQ JS RS RV GWS 
Angelus 98 97-99 95-98 17.5 19 97-99 98-100 95-98 97-100 98 94-96 99-100 93 96-98 97.17
Armailhac 94 92-94 90-92 16.5+ 17.5 94-96 91-94 91-93 94 91-93 93-94 89 92-94 92.05
Ausone 98-100 96-99 97-100 17.5+ 19.5 98-100 98-100 98-100 99 95-97 99-100 97 96-98 98.46
Batailley 94 91-94 16 17 93-95 92-94 89-92 92-94 94 92-93 94-95 89 92-94 91.86
Beausejour Duffau 98-100 97-99 94-97 15.5 96-98 98-100 95-98 95-97+ 97-98 96-98 99-100 94-96 95.54
Belair Monange 97 95-97+ 93-96 17.5 18.5 96-98 98-100 96-99 97-99 98 94-95 98-99 95-97 96.95
Beychevelle 94 95-97+ 93-96 16 18.5 95-97 96-98 94-97 94-96+ 94 94-95 93-94 90 94-96 93.75
Branaire Ducru 93 93-96 16.5 18 95-97 93-95 94-97 92-94 94 93-95 95-96 89 94-96 93.37
Brane Cantenac 95 94-96+ 92-95 16 17.5 93-95 95-97 92-94 94-95 95-96 95-96 91 94-96 93.34
Calon Segur 96 97-100 96-99 18 19 96-98 97-99 96-99 96-98 100 96-98 97-98 95 95-97 97.39
Canon (Saint Emilion) 97 96-98+ 94-97 17.5 18 95-97 97-99 96-99 97-99 98 95-97 98-99 91 95-97 96.62
Canon Gaffeliere 94 94-97 95-98 16.5 18 92-94 96-98 95-98 94-96 89 92-93 94-95 87 94-96 93.06
Cantemerle 92 86-88 15.5 17 93-95 90-92 87-90 86-88 90 89-91 94-95 88 92-94 89.80
Cantenac Brown 94 93-96 16 15 93-95 94-96 94-97 91-93 94 93-95 93-94 90 95-97 93.13
Carmes Haut Brion 98 96-98 95-98 16.5 17.5 98-100 95-98 94-96+ 96 93-95 97-98 91 92-94 95.60
Carruades Lafite 93 94-96 89-91 17.5 17.5 92-94 92-94 92-94 92-93 95-96 90 93-95 92.15
Chapelle Mission Haut Brion 92 92-94 87-89 16.5 17.5 94-96 92-94 91-93 89 90-92 93-94 89 92-94 90.33
Chasse Spleen 92 89-91 15.5 17 91-93 87-89 86 87-89 89 88.53
Cheval Blanc 98-100 97-100 97-100 18.5 18.5 98-100 98-100 97-99 100 96-98 98-99 96 96-98 98.54
Clarence Haut Brion 92 93-95 89-91 17 17.5 90-92 92-94 92-94 91 91-92 94-95 88 93-95 91.13
Clerc Milon 96 92-94 91-93 17 17.5 94-96 94-96 93-96 93-95 95-96 93-95 95-96 90 93-95 93.63
Clinet 97 96-99 91-94 16 17.5 94-96 97-99 94-96+ 95 94-95 95-96 90 94-96 93.91
Clos Fourtet 97 95-97 94-97 16 16.5 95-97 96-98 96-99 95-97 96 95-97 96-97 88 95-97 94.85
Clos Marquis 91 94-96 90-93 17 17.5 94-96 92-94 92-95 92-94 92 93-95 94-95 89 93-95 92.31
Conseillante 97 97-100 95-98 19.5 97-99 98-100 96-98+ 97 94-96 97-98 90 94-96 96.57
Cos d’Estournel 97 97-99+ 97-100 17.5 20 98-100 98-100 97-100 98 94-96 98-99 96 95-97 97.78
Coutet (Barsac) 94 16.5 17.5 90-93 93.95 92 91-92 91-92 89 95-97 91.60
Domaine Chevalier 96 96-98 94-97 17.5 17.5 94-96 96-98 94-97 94-96+ 95 94-96 99-100 89 95-97 95.21
Ducru Beaucaillou 97 97-100 95-98 17+ 20 98-100 98-100 96-99 97-99 96-98 98-99 91 96-98 96.79
Duhart Milon 95 94-96+ 88-90 17.5 17 93-95 94-96 90-93 93-95 93-95 95-96 88 93-95 92.69
Eglise Clinet 97 96-98 95-98 16.5 19 96-98 96-98 95-98 96-98 97 95-97 99-100 96.58
Evangile 97 96-98 94-97 17 18.5 98-100 97-99 97-99 94 94-96 98-99 92-94 95.72
Figeac 98 97-99 96-99 18 97-99 98-100 97-100 97-99 97 96-98 98-99 92 97-99 97.64
Fleur Petrus 96 95-97 94-97 17 18.5 96-98 97-99 96-99 94-96 97 94-96 97-98 94-96 95.87
Forts Latour 92 94-96 90-93 17 17.5 94-96 93-95 93-95+ 95 94-95 94-95 90 93-95 92.75
Gaffeliere 96 92-95 94-97 16.5 92-94 94-97 94-96 93-94 95-96 87 95-97 93.50
Gazin (Pomerol) 92 94-96 91-94 15.5 17.5 93-95 94-96 93-96 91-93 93 93-95 94-95 87 94-96 92.07
Giscours 95 93-96 17 17 94-96 94-96 93-96 90-92+ 93 92-94 96-97 91 95-97 93.72
Gloria 93 92-94 91-94 16.5 16.5 92-94 93-95 93-96 92-94 93 92-93 93-94 89 92-94 92.08
Grand Mayne 91 89-92 16 17 92-94 91-93+ 92 91-93 93-95 91.45
Grand Puy Ducasse 92 92-95 16.5 14.5 92-94 92-94 92-95 91-93 89 90-91 93-94 90 92-94 91.81
Grand Puy Lacoste 95 93-96 17.5 18.5 94-96 93-95 95-98 92-94+ 96 95-96 94-95 91 94.10
Gruaud Larose 94 89-92 16 18 94-96 93-95 95-97 95 94-95 95-96 90 92-94 92.85
Haut Bages Liberal 92 92-95 15 16.5 96-97 87 90.84
Haut Bailly 98-100 97-100 94-97 17.5 19 94-96 96-98 96-98+ 96 95-96 97-98 95-97 96.30
Haut Batailley 93 93-95+ 89-92 17 93-95 92-95 92-94 93 90-91 94-95 89 91.95
Haut Brion 98-100 97-99 93-96 17.5 19 95-97 98-100 97-99+ 96 95-96 98-99 92 96-98 96.53
Issan 96 93-95 92-95 17 17.5 94-96 94-96 94-96 92 94-96 95-96 92 93.58
Lafite Rothschild 98-100 96-98 93-96 19 19.5 95-97 98-100 98-100 96-98 99-100 97 96-98 98.12
Lafleur 98 97-99+ 97-100 18.5 19 98-100 98-100 97-100 100 97-100 100 94 98.53
Lafon Rochet 94 92-95 17 17.5 90-93 90-92+ 94 91-93 93-94 90 92.56
Lagrange Saint Julien 94 92-95 16.5 16 93-95 93-95 93-96 93-95+ 94 93-95 93-94 91 93-95 92.70
Langoa Barton 93 91-94 90-93 16.5 17.5 96-98 92-94 93-96 92-94 95 93-95 93-94 90 92-94 92.62
Larcis Ducasse 95 95-97+ 94-97 16.5 16.5 96-98 97-99 94-97 96-98 97 93-95 97-98 89 92-94 94.86
Lascombes 92 91-93 90-93 15.5 16.5 92-94 91-93 93-96 92-94 92 91-94 94-95 91 93-95 91.96
Latour 98 98-100 96-99 18 19 97-99 98-100 98-100 100 96-98 99-100 97 97-99 98.23
Leoville Barton 96 95-97+ 93-96 17 18 97-99 95-97 96-99 94-96 97 96-97 95-96 91 95-97 95.33
Leoville Las Cases 98 98-100 95-98 17 19.5 98-100 98-100 97-100 98-100 98 96-98 99-100 95 96-98 98.33
Leoville Poyferre 97 96-99 94-97 17.5 18.5 97-99 97-99 95-98 94-96+ 97 96-98 97-98 90 94-96 95.70
Lynch Bages 97 96-98+ 93-96 17 18 94-96 96-98 96-99 96-98 97 93-96 97-98 93 95-97 95.44
Malartic Lagraviere 95 91-93 92-95 16 15.5 93-95 94-96 92-95 92-94 92 92-94 95-96 89 94-96 92.47
Malescot St Exupery 93 94-96 93-96 16 16.5 93-95 95-97 93-96 94-96+ 90 94-96 97-98 90 92-94 92.80
Margaux 98 98-100 95-98 18.5 18.5 96-98 97-99 97-100 99-100 97-99 99-100 94 97-99 97.97
Mission Haut Brion 97 97-99 90-93 17.5+ 18 94-96 97-99 98-100 94 95-97 97-98 91 95-97 95.32
Monbousquet 91 92-94 89-92 15.5 14.5 91-93 91-93 94-97 93-95 90 89-90 94-95 88 91.01
Montrose 97 97-99 95-98 18+ 19 97-99 98-100 96-98 98 96-99 98-99 93 96-98 97.18
Mouton Rothschild 98-100 96-98+ 94-97 18 18.5 97-99 98-100 97-99+ 99 96-98 100 94 97-99 98.03
Ormes Pez 93 91-93+ 89-91 16.5 17 92-94 90-93 90-92 91 90-91 93-94 88 90.83
Pagodes Cos 92 92-94 91-94 17 17 93-95 93-95 93-95 92 92-93 94-95 89 92-94 92.30
Palmer 98-100 95-97+ 95-98 18.5 19.5 95-97 98-100 97-100 97-99 98 96-98 94-95 94 97-99 97.29
Pape Clement 95 95-97+ 93-96 16.5 17.5 95-97 96-98 95-98 96-98 96 93-95 97-98 90 94-96 94.61
Pavie 96 98-100 94-97 17 18.5 95-97 96-100 96-99 97-100 94-95 98-99 92 95.99
Pavie Decesse 94 97-100 92-95 16 14.5 93-95 95-97 95-98 96-98 90-93 97-98 90 93.75
Pavie Macquin 98 97-99 92-95 16.5 17.5 97-99 97-99 95-98 95-97 98 92-95 97-98 91 94-96 95.55
Pavillon Rouge 92 93-95 91-94 17 17.5 93-95 92-94 93-95 94 93-95 95-96 89 92-94 92.50
Petit Mouton 92 93-95 90-93 16.5 16.5 94-96 94-96 91-94 92-94+ 92 93-94 97-98 89 91.96
Petit Village 93 91-93 90-93 17 17.5 92-95 90-92+ 91 96-97 91 92-94 92.23
Petrus 98 98-100 97-100 18.5 19 98-100 98-100 98-100 98 97-98 100 97-99 99.03
Phelan Segur 94 92-94+ 91-94 17 16 93-95 93-95 90-93 93-95 91 92-93 95-96 88 91-93 92.18
Pichon Baron 97 97-99 94-97 18 19 97-99 97-99 95-98 97-99 98 97-99 97-98 93 96-98 96.88
Pichon Lalande 98-100 96-98+ 95-98 17.5 18.5 96-98 98-100 97-100 97-99 97-98 95-98 98-99 92 96-98 97.21
Pin 98 97-99 94-97 18.5 19 96-98 96-98 97-99 95-96 98-99 96 97.04
Pontet Canet 96 96-98 96-99 16.5 18 94-96 97-99 97-99 94-97 97-98 96 96-98 96.13
Quinault l’Enclos 94 92-94 91-94 17.5 17 93-95 89-91 92-94 93 91-92 93-94 89 92-94 91.97
Quintus 94 89-92 16 17 94-96 94-96 94-96 93 92-94 93-94 92.62
Rauzan Segla 97 96-98 97-100 16.5+ 17.5 97-99 96-99 97-99+ 96 96-98 99-100 92 96.12
Reserve Comtesse 93 92-94 89-92 16.5 92-94 90-92 90-93 92-94+ 92 89-92 93-94 90 91.33
Rieussec 94 17.5 17.5 91-93 93.95 92 92-94 93-94 94 94-96 93.24
Saint Pierre 95 94-97 92-95 16 17.5 96-98 94-96 92-95 94-96 97 94-96 93-94 89 93.01
Smith Haut Lafitte 98 97-100 90-93 17 18 96-98 97-99 95-98 97-99+ 95 94-95 98-99 91 95-97 96.01
Sociando Mallet 94 90-93 16.5 18 92-94 90-93 85-87 92 91-93 94-95 91.90
Suduiraut 94 93-95 17 17.5 93-95 91-94 93.95 94 92-93 97-98 94 94-96 93.90
Talbot 94 93-95 91-94 16.5+ 17.5 95-97 92-94 93-96 91-93 92 94-95 94-95 89 93-95 92.64
Tertre 92 89-92 17 15 92-94 91-93 91-94 89-91 90 91-93 94-95 87 94-96 91.40
Troplong Mondot 97 94-96 94-97 17.5 18 95-97 87-89 95-98 93-95+ 97 95-97 97-98 92 95-97 95.88
Trotanoy 98-100 97-100 96-99 17.5 18.5 97-99 98-100 97-100 97-99+ 99 94-95 98-99 95-97 97.92
Valandraud 96 96-98 94-97 16.5+ 96-98 96-98 96-99 95-97+ 96 92-94 97-98 90 96-98 95.62
Vieux Chateau Certan 98-100 96-98 94-97 18.5 19.5 97-99 98-100 97-100 96-98 99-100 96 98-100 98.31

Sources

AG = Antonio Galloni (Vinous)

CK = Chris Kissack (Wine Doctor)

GQ = Gavin Quinney (Gavin Quinney)

GWS = Global Wine Score (Globalwinescore.com)

JA = Jane Anson (Decanter)

JD = Jeb Dunnuck (JebDunnuck.com)

JH = Julia Harding (JancisRobinson.com)

JL = Jeff Leve (The Wine Cellar Insider)

JM = James Molesworth (Wine Spectator)

JMQ = Jean-Marc Quarin (Quarin)

JS = James Suckling (James Suckling)

LPB = Lisa Perotti-Brown (Wine Advocate)

MJ = Matthew Jukes (Matthew Jukes)

NM = Neal Martin (Vinous)

RS = Roderick Smith (Tim Atkin)

RV = Roger Voss (Wine Enthusiast)

The smartest way to price, source and sell wine

Join Liv-ex